Books & Lit
Comments 4

‘The New York Trilogy’ by Paul Auster ~ A Review


If you like puzzles or riddles with no clear answers, you might just enjoy this.

I picked it, in an effort to follow up on my decision to read more of the “classics”. The premise sounded original & intriguing (fact which, I feel, made my eventual disappointment even more bitter. High expectations an’all…)

Now, I am not one to easily dislike a book but I can, honestly, say I hated this 😦 I slogged through the stories, feeling like I was having my teeth pulled and desperately trying not to give up. In fact, had this book not been part of my blog TBR challenge, I would have definitely spared myself the pain.

I remember reading a review that said “Somewhere along the way Paul Auster was decreed a “literary author,” so if you dare to say he’s boring, pretentious, and not really all that good with words, you are simply one of the great unwashed who don’t get it.” I am willing to take my chances…

The three, separate narratives are supposed to be interconnected -with the final story sheding light on the first two. There’s even a bunch of cross-references throughout which however, sadly, made absolutely no sense to me – much like the rest of the book. Despite Auster’s confident & highly stylized writing (or maybe because of it), it all felt like self-important, non-sensical, pointless drivel to me. And if that makes me one of the “great unwashed”, then so be it 🙄

Overall verdict on Mr. Auster’s effort: NOT recommended ~ proceed with caution and at own risk…

Lifestyle Counter Rating 



  1. Are you sure you read it? Could there have been a different book inside the cover? There are few novelists I could recommend as highly as Mr Auster.
    If you haven’t given up on him entirely you might like his ‘Mr Vertigo’ better.

  2. Hey, thanks for dropping by & taking the time to leave a comment 🙂

    Yup, persevered and got through the whole thing in the end -not one for leaving things half-done, really.

    Still haven’t completely given up on Auster, though. His writing style was highly original and interesting -so I think he deserves another chance at some later date 😉

    Have also heard good things about his “Brooklyn Follies” -is “Mr. Vertigo” better?

  3. Mr Vertigo is highly entertaining (though some of it is quite dark)
    my kids read it and enjoyed it when they were teenagers

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s